Lupin III: Green vs Red — Unlimited Lupin Works

April 5th, 2008

 

Freakiest Reality Marble ever.

Impressions:

Let me preface this by saying that while I like Lupin a lot, I’m not a rabid fan and actually haven’t really seen the majority of it. In particular, I never saw the Lupin vs the Clone movie which I imagine contributed a lot of similar themes and ideas as this one. Still, late night Lupin was fun times when I got tired of problem sets in college, so I have at least a passing fondness for the cast.

I have to say that I wasn’t a huge fan though. Two of my favorite characters in the series are Fujiko and Goemon and they were basically completely absent except for a few relatively unimportant and brief parts. Instead, we got a billion Lupins all running around. One of them got caught shoplifting from a convenience store (of all things) and then the rest of the INFINITE LUPINS converged from around the world to break him out because he’s ruining their gigs seducing women as Lupin impersonators. All of them get caught, except for one pickpocket who has more or less repressed his  Lupin-imitator instincts to become a scruffy bum, yet daydreams about living the life of a Lupin through the entire flick and what sets it apart from most Lupin stuff. The whole thing is kind of a bizarre question of who is Lupin instead of his usual wacky antics. Sometimes it worked, a lot of times it didn’t.

Green Lupin (far more competent and quick to resort to violence) declares that there are too many imitators out there, so he’s going to do something really amazing and prove that he’s the real one. That conversation was all in deadpan English and was absolutely unintentionally hilarious. "Mistake is not an option!" "It’s a threat to steal!" That one’s also a fake, but he draws the real’s interest who meets with him in the disguise of Jigen and basically cockblocks him. Things continue from there with the stolen data on Ice Cube, some revolutionary sciencey -thing- that will do "I don’t even know what."

They tried to do some interesting things stylistically on occasion, but they honestly looked pretty awful. For example, the showdown at the end suddenly went into black and white line drawings instead of the usual animation. They used switches like that quite a few times in fact, and it always looked bad in my opinion. It was like the style shifting in that Zetsubou Sensei episode… only at more or less completely random. Some of them didn’t even make sense… like some kid the Green Lupin saved got beaned with a laptop and had a watercolor flashback to his father strangling him… then was blown up by a missle 90 seconds later. The whole fake Lupin thing would also have been a lot more interesting if the real Lupin’s voice wasn’t so distinctive and the fake’s so… well… different. The moment they open their mouths, you can easily tell the real from the fake.

It was overall pretty well done aside from those stylistic quirks. The main problem I have is that for a Lupin production, there really wasn’t that much of Lupin and what Lupin there was had him as more gritty and idealized than the usual philandering, letchy, witty and comical guy that I know and love. It’s quite different, and I’m not sure it was better, but I at least got what they were going for. So much of the focus was on the Green Lupin and the daydreaming pickpocket proto-Lupin that it just didn’t have the same charm and the whole thing was just needlessly convoluted and really didn’t need to be. Hell, like I said, Fujiko and Goemon were barely on the screen and Jigen was around only slightly more. All three combined had about as much screentime as hobo Lupin. Aside from my disappointments there though, it was a pretty solid story and did stay engaging throughout, so I can’t complain too strenuously. Still, in a 70 minutes featuring about 80 different Lupins, I find myself wishing that there had been more Lupin, if that makes any sense to anybody else.

Caps are pretty sparse in comparison to usual (it was basically a full 70 minute movie), just FYI.

Posted in Lupin III | 4 Comments »

4 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • jason says:

    Which lupin is the real one? Did the daydreaming lupin end up becoming the real one or what? I didn’t quite understand the end. Could somebody please explain to me what was deal with the old lady at the end.

  • henry says:

    man… that was the most confusing lupin movie ever. i personally thought it was the worst, but by the end i realized what the purpose of this movie was… as opposed to all other lupin movies.

    it seems that instead of illustrating a grand adventure this time, the directors wanted to show what kind of a person Lupin really is. Lupin must be free, eager.. blah blah… hence how there can be so many fake Lupins, but most of them got caught. This shows that it takes a lot more than a colored suit and a walther p38 to be Lupin.

    Anyways the scruffy Lupin impersonator was not actually a Lupin until the end of the movie when the police say “We found Lupin! It’s a new one!” We basically followed his story on the side… and watch how he becomes a Lupin impersonator while the original and a fake duke it out.

    All in all, i don’t suggest this movie unless you want to do some deep thinking about the “Lupin” philosophy… More thinking than action in this movie. :]

  • Phineas J Whoopie says:

    “All who can be Lupin, will be Lupin! ”

    This is a far darker Lupin than any of the others. All the characters wander through the movie in a perpetual state of low level angst, consumed by the project of being (or being partnered with) the “real” Lupin as an antidote to their “real” lives. Ultimately none of them are “real” or more “real” than any other. What I liked best was the play between the “real” police detective (a hibakusha) and Zenigata. Perhaps an existential Lupin has no place in the ranks of “real” Lupin adventures, but it remains a favourite.

  • muuu says:

    After watching it, I can tell you: Worst Lupin Movie Ever.
    The confusing plot is plenty of questions to the viewer. The episode with the robot is awful. The Lupin sidekicks play a minor role and at the end you don’t care about the red or green lupins, you end with the impression that so great animation was wasted.

    Reading impressions about it, the truth behind the scenes is that they had to renew the dubbing voices as they grew old. So, they tried to create a sort of “homage”, but not a real movie with beggining, middle and end.

    Not good.