Soul Eater #01 — Robble Robble Robble

April 7th, 2008

 

 Obligatory shonen post.

Impressions:

I don’t have a particularly good relationship with shonen stuff, as you might have been able to deduce. It isn’t helped by the fanbase. You can set your watch by the ranting about new shows. It’s basically a yearly ordeal where One Piece, Naruto, Fullmetal Alchemist, Bleach, D.Grey Man, Claymore, etc gets praised as the second coming of the holy ghost and within two months, the animation budget has dried up and characters are spending episodes alternatively arguing about their power levels, giving detailed Powerpoint lectures on how their magical power is better than the other person’s magical power or for some reason… now in a tournament.

I’ll say this for Soul Eater at the very least… it starts a lot stronger than everything I’ve mentioned above. Unfortunately, it has its own slew of problems unique. The voice acting is completely flat and horrendous, the background artwork is about forty times better than the foreground, it took only 10 minutes before it was making boob jokes and nose bleeds all over the place and I think actually managed to make more cracks about breasts than even To Love-ru, and the mouth animation is… let’s call it inconsistent. It was extremely well animated otherwise, though hampered by some really awful fight direction. The choreography and animation was top notch, but the camera lept around like a hyperactive frog on speed which made it impossible to actually follow a damn thing. The mouths also… the first two thirds of the episode, they were just poorly animated. Snapping back and forth between completely closed and jaw splitting in a single frame. Then all of a sudden at the end they became extremely overanimated to the point where Maka and Soul looked like they were having seizures as they talked.

If none of those things bother you (and if you’re a sub watcher, you won’t be paying too much attention to the spastic mouths anyway), then it was a great first episode. Like every other shonen show from here to Dragonball and beyond though, I remain skeptical that it’ll be anywhere near as impressive in a month. Luckily, I don’t think anybody expects me to cover this anyway. This kind of stuff is more Omni’s domain… or the swarm of everybody else eager to jump on the latest and greatest shonen show before the power level debates begin.

Soul Eater OP

Preview:

One of the rivals/friends gets an episode.

Posted in Anime | 16 Comments »

16 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • byakugan says:

    Soul Eater !!!
    Thank you for the good one.
    It keeps favorite of me.
    http://japanese-naruto-anime.blogspot.com/
    Please link to this site.

  • dangan says:

    I luv this manga I know that I am going to luv the anime as well

  • FhnuZoag says:

    Oh dear, you just (off handly, and implicitly) insulted FMA.

    And it’s totally unfair. The bros don’t gain *any* fighting powers over the series, never get involved in a tournament, and there’s no such thing as power levels, and the animation quality never obviously declined.

  • Aroduc says:

    Actually, I’d say that I pretty explicitly insulted it. ^^

  • longhaul says:

    man they clamped down on copies of the OP on youtube

  • Ryan A says:

    Mah, agree with the VA and mount-sync ordeal. I enjoyed it though, I found the animation setting and general quality attractive.

  • Westlo says:

    I didn’t find the fight camera hard to follow at all.

  • SOSAnimeBoy says:

    This is like the lovechild of FLCL and Gurren Lagann…

  • Denizen says:

    I think you are being very harsh on this show. It is far better than you make it out to be.

    The VAs are fitting, the action was nicely choreographed and the angles just added that extra element of excitement to it. The art and animation is brilliant, even if it contrasts.
    My only complaint is the fanservice, but that was standard shounen fair in 2003, so what can you expect?
    And the music, admit it was good.

    In my opinion, the bad points of shounen did not show up in this pilot, so why are you letting those judgements cloud this?

  • Westlo says:

    Just a note the first 3 episodes or Prologue 1, 2 and 3 as they seem to be called are based on 3 one shot/short stories that were popular. So the author combined all 3 into one series and episode 4 is Chapter 01: Extra Lessons. The soul collecting thing is dropped very quickly and the main villain is shown very quickly.

  • Gil says:

    Actually, this is like Bandit Jing King, but crappier designs.

  • Tokki says:

    I like the animaton style. So I might stick with this one.

  • albert_2mb says:

    actually this title is quite promising, but the main girl’s seiyuu really puts me off >_> like you said, absolutely flat and horrendous >_<

  • biki says:

    Me too. I think the animation style is really great

  • Tsu-kun says:

    It’s like D. Gray man, only the action is faster and the main character is the offspring of a scythe.

  • me says:

    I used to like Soul Eater, but just realixed it is racist as hell. The charachter Excaliber is a veiled shot at white viewers. He has beady round eyes, a long hooked nose, European clothes, a connection to English myth, and is coloured entirely white. Kind of insulting.